| First Round, August 12, 2009 |
| (1) Chris Mackey df (16) Lynea Gustafson 7&5 |
| (8) Marcus Aiello df (9) Dillon Stiles 5&4 |
| (4) Josh Stauffer df (13) Paul DePalma 8&7 |
| (5) Corey Haas df (12) John Andhor 1 up |
| (2) Scott Brady df (15) Garrett Crouch 9&8 |
| (7) Matt Domboski df (10) Zachary Hyman 4&2 |
| (3) John Forrest df (14) Dylan Gethicker 5&4 |
| (11) Eric Morton df (6) Brandon Haas 2 up |
|
| Quarterfinals August 14, 2009 |
| (1) Chris Mackey df (8) Marcus Aiello 1 up |
| (4) Josh Stauffer df (5) Corey Haas 6&5 |
| (2) Scott Brady df (7) Matt Domboski 6&5 |
| (3) John Forrest df (11) Eric Morton 1 up |
|
| Semifinals August 15, 2009 AM |
| (4) Josh Stauffer df (1) Chris Mackey 1 up 19 holes |
| (3) John Forrest df (2) Scott Brady 1 up 20 holes |
|
| Finals August 15, 2009 PM |
| (3) John Forrest df (4) Josh Stauffer 5&3 |